Self Ownership vs Individual Rights
This is a short audio where L. Peikoff suggests that self-ownership is a non-concept because it implies a relationship between you and something. However, I find many Rand quotes that contradict this position.
"Without property rights, no other rights are possible." and "If a producer does not own the result of his own effort, he does not own his life." I agree that owning oneself is not axiomatic, but it is derived from Rand based on the fact you are a rational animal. Locke recognized this in formulating natural rights. First, if we say Man, due to his unique nature, has a right to life (as Peikoff says). well, this doesn't get you very far. ok-you have a right to life. so what? But if we say, as Rand says, you own yourself, it includes the right to your life-but it includes much more: the right to the products of your mind, it explains the source of property rights, who has legitimate property rights, why you can contract, why most of our common/criminal law exists. What say you?
p.s. please, for the purposes of this post, let's not discuss religious concepts of God given rights.
"Without property rights, no other rights are possible." and "If a producer does not own the result of his own effort, he does not own his life." I agree that owning oneself is not axiomatic, but it is derived from Rand based on the fact you are a rational animal. Locke recognized this in formulating natural rights. First, if we say Man, due to his unique nature, has a right to life (as Peikoff says). well, this doesn't get you very far. ok-you have a right to life. so what? But if we say, as Rand says, you own yourself, it includes the right to your life-but it includes much more: the right to the products of your mind, it explains the source of property rights, who has legitimate property rights, why you can contract, why most of our common/criminal law exists. What say you?
p.s. please, for the purposes of this post, let's not discuss religious concepts of God given rights.
SOURCE URL: http://www.peikoff.com/?s=self-ownership