Free Market Revolution: How Ayn Rand’s Ideas Can End Big Government
Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 10 years, 4 months ago to Books
Free Market Revolution: How Ayn Rand’s Ideas Can End Big Government
Authors, Yaron Brook and Don Watkins Economics, 221 pages. ISBN 978-1-137-27838-8
A great introduction and collection of Ayn Rand’s most powerful arguments in support of free market capitalism and small government: this book should be distributed to those with limited time but open minds. For those well read in these matters, there will be little new material, but this book has compiled the most powerful excerpts into one modest volume.
With supporting arguments from notables from various schools of economics, the founding fathers and prominent objectivist thinkers it makes the moral case for capitalism. Also included are the errors of past supporters that facilitated the inroads of the statists. The thrust of the book is the failure of utilitarian argument persuasion of the masses. For too long the arguments have been focused on lack of superior alternatives, practicality, greater good, general welfare and a multitude of platitudes and half measures designed to placate the mixed market crowd which was a recipe for slow demise. These arguments have largely fallen on deaf ears and been ineffective. The moral argument must be made. The altruists have made an effective emotional argument and not been well countered. It is time to force the issue… to make the moral case and point out the lack of morality in the redistributive policies of the big government statists, as well as the harm and failures.
Politically, the majority of self proclaimed supposed proponents of capitalism have been weak. There is little difference between them and their opponents. It has only been lip service or matters of degree. They have been facilitators acquiescing and folding under the altruist’s arguments and political pressure. The outcome has been predictable. The State has gained power and the individual has lost sovereignty, rights and liberty.
“To visualize the predicament of America, imagine passengers riding on a train which, they have been told, is taking them to a distant utopia. At first it seems well, but as the train moves closer to its destination, the scene outside the windows becomes ominously bleak. Finally, the passengers catch sight of the destination in the distance. Instead of utopia, they see hungry children, chain gangs, and, in the far distance, the barbed wire and sentry posts of a concentration camp. Frightened, angry, they attempt to negate their forward motion by running back inside the train. The attempt, of course, is hopeless; to save themselves, the passengers must get off the train altogether.” Harry Binswanger
The moral case: One’s need is not a license to steal or legitimate claim to the property or wealth of others. Forced redistribution is theft.
“…misfortune is not a claim to slave labor; there is no such thing as a right to consume, control, and destroy those without whom one would be unable to survive.” Ayn Rand “Does that sound harsh? Consider your own case: Would you regard your hardships as a claim on your neighbor’s paycheck? Would you march into his house waving your need around like a gun and helping yourself to his food or his medicine cabinet? Would you think very much of a neighbor who did that to you?” pg. 189
The prescription:
“. The ultimate abolition of all entitlement programs including Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, and public education
. The abolition of all government controls on business
. The privatization of all property, including public lands, utilities, and roads
. The repeal of all business subsidies and other forms of corporate welfare
. The resurrection of private money (i.e,, a gold standard), the abolishment of the Federal Reserve, and the establishment of free banking
. A restoration of freedom of trade and sanctity of contract
In short, our goal must be the total separation of state and economics.” Pg. 217
A little socialism is like a little untreated cancer.
Some of the arguments did give me pause to reconsider my dedication to particular predilections. Some were reinforced while others have taken a lower place in my hierarchy. The compact, concentrated arguments in this volume can be persuasive.
Definitely a handy book worthy of a place in your library and one worthy of offering to those open minds looking for arguments and options to a failed system.
Happy reading!
O.A.
Authors, Yaron Brook and Don Watkins Economics, 221 pages. ISBN 978-1-137-27838-8
A great introduction and collection of Ayn Rand’s most powerful arguments in support of free market capitalism and small government: this book should be distributed to those with limited time but open minds. For those well read in these matters, there will be little new material, but this book has compiled the most powerful excerpts into one modest volume.
With supporting arguments from notables from various schools of economics, the founding fathers and prominent objectivist thinkers it makes the moral case for capitalism. Also included are the errors of past supporters that facilitated the inroads of the statists. The thrust of the book is the failure of utilitarian argument persuasion of the masses. For too long the arguments have been focused on lack of superior alternatives, practicality, greater good, general welfare and a multitude of platitudes and half measures designed to placate the mixed market crowd which was a recipe for slow demise. These arguments have largely fallen on deaf ears and been ineffective. The moral argument must be made. The altruists have made an effective emotional argument and not been well countered. It is time to force the issue… to make the moral case and point out the lack of morality in the redistributive policies of the big government statists, as well as the harm and failures.
Politically, the majority of self proclaimed supposed proponents of capitalism have been weak. There is little difference between them and their opponents. It has only been lip service or matters of degree. They have been facilitators acquiescing and folding under the altruist’s arguments and political pressure. The outcome has been predictable. The State has gained power and the individual has lost sovereignty, rights and liberty.
“To visualize the predicament of America, imagine passengers riding on a train which, they have been told, is taking them to a distant utopia. At first it seems well, but as the train moves closer to its destination, the scene outside the windows becomes ominously bleak. Finally, the passengers catch sight of the destination in the distance. Instead of utopia, they see hungry children, chain gangs, and, in the far distance, the barbed wire and sentry posts of a concentration camp. Frightened, angry, they attempt to negate their forward motion by running back inside the train. The attempt, of course, is hopeless; to save themselves, the passengers must get off the train altogether.” Harry Binswanger
The moral case: One’s need is not a license to steal or legitimate claim to the property or wealth of others. Forced redistribution is theft.
“…misfortune is not a claim to slave labor; there is no such thing as a right to consume, control, and destroy those without whom one would be unable to survive.” Ayn Rand “Does that sound harsh? Consider your own case: Would you regard your hardships as a claim on your neighbor’s paycheck? Would you march into his house waving your need around like a gun and helping yourself to his food or his medicine cabinet? Would you think very much of a neighbor who did that to you?” pg. 189
The prescription:
“. The ultimate abolition of all entitlement programs including Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, and public education
. The abolition of all government controls on business
. The privatization of all property, including public lands, utilities, and roads
. The repeal of all business subsidies and other forms of corporate welfare
. The resurrection of private money (i.e,, a gold standard), the abolishment of the Federal Reserve, and the establishment of free banking
. A restoration of freedom of trade and sanctity of contract
In short, our goal must be the total separation of state and economics.” Pg. 217
A little socialism is like a little untreated cancer.
Some of the arguments did give me pause to reconsider my dedication to particular predilections. Some were reinforced while others have taken a lower place in my hierarchy. The compact, concentrated arguments in this volume can be persuasive.
Definitely a handy book worthy of a place in your library and one worthy of offering to those open minds looking for arguments and options to a failed system.
Happy reading!
O.A.
Atlas Shrugged did not advocate collapse. It was an illustration in fiction of the role of man's mind in his existence by showing what happens when the mind is withdrawn. The highly accelerated process of collapse hastened further by the efforts of a few people was a fictional device, not an advocacy of collapse or an advocacy or description of a means to cause or accelerate it.
The question becomes more acute when there is increasing, real danger in remaining where you live, whether Cuba, Nazi Germany, etc. The question today is what is possible by moving somewhere else for an improvement given the decline of this country and the increasing threat it poses to its own citizens, what is possible to improve the situation in major or minor ways through the spread of better ideas, and how much of any of it is worth doing at what expense to your own life given what may or may not be possible.
I do say that after the collapse, you'll still have gang warfare for years afterward.
Ayn Rand — 'You can avoid reality, but you cannot avoid the consequences of avoiding reality.'
Yes they seem to be ubiquitous and winning... Yet, your actions demonstrate that you will keep trying/fighting. I hope together we can eventually wear them out. They must be beaten back. It is the constant struggle between good and evil. Is it not? I will not sanction evil. Neither do you.
We must gain the upper-hand. Suffering can only go on for so long and then sunlight will disinfect.
Keep shining the light.
O.A.
They need to get the idea out of their heads that they are "entitled" to any *positive goods,* whether you or I wish to provide them or not.
Herculean perhaps, but worth the attempt...
I do not know.... I do know I am unwilling to let them win without protest. In the end I can only work for those like you and I so that we might receive what should be our birthright.
Yes, but AR's ideas can inspire the would be Ragnars and Galts. They may propagate the conditions for that implosion.
Just a thought..
Happy New Year,
O.A.
You could be right, but I will not go down without a fight. I hope we can raise our voices and show others they are not alone. If things do not change for the better, at least I will be able to keep my self respect. I do not wish to find myself apologizing to my posterity for having done too little.
It is not much, but it is not in me to be too fatalistic.
Perhaps I am romantic and nostalgic...
Happy New Year,
O.A.
"I think that the important point in the above excerpt is that it is critical, absolutely essential, to have a strong conceptual reply to the ideal of altruism."
Exactly. We must make the moral case for capitalism and demonstrate the lack thereof of altruism. We must not shy away from the moral argument and stop stressing the practical alone. We must provide favorable arguments on all fronts thus appealing to not only the intellect, but the emotion. Many people must be convinced and some, unfortunately, are emotionally driven. Only after they are reached in this way can some see the logic...
Happy New Year,
O.A.
It does seem that way. Robbie is justified in his skepticism, however, I hold out hope for the rare, but possible revolution like our own (hopefully this time peaceful). One does not know when the last straw has been reached, enough people awaken and question the direction or when critical mass has been reached and political sea change could occur. It only takes a determined vocal minority to change the course of a nation. Unfortunately the progressive, statists have learned this lesson all too well in the last century. Those who wish to fight for the right... for liberty and freedom must once again take the lead and combat the forces of Marxism.
Happy New Year,
O.A.
So it would seem. Most people go on blindly pulling the cart like Boxer from Orwell's Animal Farm. I am encouraged that there are many like those that frequent this board, that will be able to offer direction if/when the train goes off the rails. One day the piper will have to be paid.
Happy New Year,
O.A.
Load more comments...