Sociopath? Really???
Posted by Ragnell 10 years, 1 month ago to The Gulch: General
May I ask for input here? I very often hear Ayn Rand described as a sociopath by her detractors. This irks me no end. Can anyone enlighten me as to why this is the ad hominem attack of choice? How do you respond to this?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 2.
Jan
What a great place to learn with amazing faculty, too.
If one of these theftists* tries it on me, I point out that his "heroes" (Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Castro, Che) all murdered millions, and ask if he really wants to call the kettle black!
* A word for leftists, coined by Robert Ringer in "Restoring The American Dream".
The word has come to have a fuzzy meaning as someone who doesn't fit into a society in some sort of dangerous way.
I certainly think that Rand was more than aware of the various ills of society, even of the U.S. when compared to Soviet Russia. And, since she was vocal about what she observed and thought, she was indeed a student of society. Remember that she was the one who taught most of us to define your terms, so we will know what we are talking about. You might meet someone who uses the tern for his definition, and then ask him how that applies to Rand. It won't.
I usually am ruthless with such people, ending the discussion, such as it is, on my terms, by saying something on the order of "I see that you know nothing about either the word you are using or the person you are describing. Why am I still talking to you?"
N.B. my husband is continually concerned that I will cut myself on the razor edges of my tongue. I think it doesn't work that way.
I wish I had time to spend just reading and absorbing all this.
I wish this was taught in school.
You might as well argue with a wall, which you could at least objectively bounce an idea off of.
If you just want to get whizzed-off, you might as well just hit your thumb with a hammer and get it over with.
It's been years, but in college I took as many Philosophy courses as I could, and in the so-called "open discussion" classes, mentioning Ayn Rand once ensured that you were never called on again...pure fear.
Load more comments...