[Ask the Gulch] Gulch points, one more time. Can anyone help clarify?
Posted by Bethesda-gal 9 years, 5 months ago to Ask the Gulch
Since the recent post about points I've been trying to understand better, so I read the FAQ page and it doesn't look like people are following the FAQ guidelines re: voting things up or down. Can anyone help clarify?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 3.
The ignores are due to boredom and cutting down on useless commentary. Without Exception.
I haven't flagged anyone.
I suppose the system is useful. No doubt. But it introduces a bit of game playing with restart buttons and subtracts from thoughtful commentary.. NOW to 'fess up that does not include Bidenesque Hillary jokes. So I'm tarred with my own brush. Thus the first stone is cast at myself. i am not completely without sin.
Generally, I like to think that Objectivists are interested in pursuing the truth, wherever that may lead them, even being patient to deal with people's ignorance, even being willing to look past arrogance and rudeness. Objectivists should have a thick skin, being able to see through the crap and cut to the issue. But that is not always the case.
That said, I think the system described in the FAQ is good, and is followed (except in a relatively few hot-topic exceptions). Regardless of what others do, I encourage you to be pro-active in following the system. Up-vote comments you find constructive. Use the down-vote not just from things you don't like, or from things you wish you hadn't seen, but in particular for comments that distract from the real issue. When you down-vote, it may be helpful to indicate why you did that.
That said for blatantly bad posts such as name calling or doing the same to entire groups I've no qualm down voting without commentary. I feel it should be obvious under such circumstances. Personally that is what I "save" down voting for: outright asshattery. Everything above that line gets nothing or if particularly insightful (I have a pretty high bar for that though - Slashdot taught me that) a thumbs up.