OK, I followed the recommendations here, and discovered that it was user error. The e-mail address I was using was with cable company that stopped providing service. So, my notifications were going there. Thanks for the help. I changed it, and all is well in Smallsvill.

Thanks, and I will turn that on! I only get to log in here a couple days a week, so I miss quite a bit.

And No, Khalling I would not ignore you! I love reading your stuff!
Thanks again!

brewer, definitely turn on that feature! so this is why I thought you didn't like me ;)

People can reply directly to you and you would never know it unless you remember to check back.

Thanks for this input brewer. This has come up before and we take this as a hardy +1.
We have actively talked about doing this. I can't promise it nor can I promise a time-frame, but I will champion this feature as best I can.

On a side note, if you like you can turn on email notifications in your settings http://www.galtsgulchonline.com/account/...
This will alert you to replies to your own comments and / or comments on posts you originate. I realize this is not the same thing as what you are suggesting, but it may be helpful to you or others reading this.