Jason Brennan Joins the Brigade of People Misrepresenting Ayn Rand’s Views
Posted by Zenphamy 10 years, 9 months ago to Philosophy
" blog post by Jason Brennan of Bleeding Heart Libertarians, in which Brennan claims (among other things) that Rand and Objectivists are, according to the implications of ethical egoism, “committed to the view that you should rape, dismember, and murder others when it serves your interests.” Of course, Brennan does not and cannot quote Rand saying or implying this or anything of the sort. Nor does he or can he get around the fact that the implications of Rand’s ethics are precisely the opposite of what he claims them to be—as Rand herself made clear."
Is this going to be Objectivists battle for ever? Or is it a major indicator of the successes of AR's philosophy?
Is this going to be Objectivists battle for ever? Or is it a major indicator of the successes of AR's philosophy?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 8.
"The only “obligation” involved in individual rights is an obligation imposed, not by the state, but by the nature of reality (i.e., by the law of identity): consistency, which, in this case, means the obligation to respect the rights of others, if one wishes one’s own rights to be recognized and protected."
If you know how a quantum computer operates and wish to explain, please do. That in and of itself would be confirmation/rejection of my hypotheses - well-reasoned or ill-informed as they may be.
Seriously, I think you've hit the proverbial nail on the head. Definitely +1
My uncle often said:
"The masses are asses."
1) The wet nurse.
2) Owen Kellogg
Maphesdus constantly makes things up in the repeated misrepresentations of his agenda to trash Ayn Rand. He obsessively grasps at anything he can find to cite "refutations" -- that is, anything he can find except reading and understanding what Ayn Rand actually thought and why, or accurately and honestly portraying it as what it is.
This latest example invokes Bloom -- a previously very good chemist who at the age of 80 tried to dabble in philosophy by publishing a very bad book repeating time-worn philosophical fallacies to a wished for popular audience. Contrary to Maphesdus it is not "about quantum mechanics", not that Maphesdus could know enough about either philosophy or quantum mechanics to know the difference.
Neither does it, contrary to Maphesdus, "directly address Ayn Rand's theories". He quotes from Atlas Shrugged on "A is A" (and nothing else) without understanding what she is talking about and proceeds to confuse it with mathematical equality, followed by other philosophical fallacies that are as old as Heraclitus. He "directly addresses" Objectivism in the following polemical way (with nothing else on her "theories"): "One of the strangest uses of A = A is in pop philosophy. The followers of Russian American novelist and philosophical thinker Ayn Rand, author of Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead, have adopted A=A as their slogan. These 'objectivists' chant 'A is A' like a mantra to ward off evil thoughts." And that's it. Maphesdus is dishonest.
This is the kind of crap that Maphesdus relies on as a substitute for reading Ayn Rand and peddles in the name of "refutations" "directly addressing" Ayn Rand as he dishonestly trashes her for being against "science" and claims that "anyone who considers themselves a serious student of Objectivist philosophy should read this book". And no, the book isn't any good for understanding "quantum mechanics", either, which would require reading the standard reputable texts and histories of the subject, which are all over his head.
Maphesdus is perversely, intransigently ignorant, not very brights, intellectually dishonest, and has a bizarre psycho agenda obsessed with trashing
Ayn Rand. He has no credibility, is malevolently motivated, and does not belong here.
That conflation in people's minds brought about by the mistaken belief that government will take care of you, leads to the prevalence of Robbie's drug gangs. If the individual or the neighborhood doesn't stand up to the first drug dealer then the gang will follow. Self defense has to happen in order to maintain liberty.
Load more comments...