Public or Private? Does the Government have the power to protect speech even on private platforms?
It is an interesting question. If and When does a company get big enough that its reach becomes not merely private but public in nature?
Of course, the other question is why have we not clarified the bill protecting internet service providers to note that editing or suppressing content on such platforms voids these protections - most notably immunity from libel/slander and tax breaks - under that bill?
Of course, the other question is why have we not clarified the bill protecting internet service providers to note that editing or suppressing content on such platforms voids these protections - most notably immunity from libel/slander and tax breaks - under that bill?
All Comments
- 1Posted by $ blarman 2 years, 2 months ago in reply to this comment.No one is arguing any different for traditional media companies. The question is more geared around the social media companies: Google, Facebook/Meta, Twitter, etc. In a world where so many people access these platforms, do they have a legal responsibility to abide by their own terms of service and not censor and do the People - through their government - have the right to prosecute them for not upholding Free Speech - especially since they claim protection from libel/slander?Permalink|
- Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
- 1Posted by $ blarman 2 years, 2 months ago in reply to this comment.While I don't deny that the government involvement is a direct violation of the First Amendment, the speaker in the clip makes the point that insofar as companies (publicly-traded BTW) engage in control of the mediums of conversation and speech, they tread into areas where they take upon themselves a duty to maintain a free society: and that means allowing free speech on equitable terms. I would simply clarify that there is a significant difference between sponsoring and/or curating content such as that engaged in by a media company and simply proving a marketplace for thought to happen. Right now, companies are doing both - and claiming that their activities are protected.Permalink|
- Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment