[Ask the Gulch] If you were tasked with designing a health care system to replace Obamacare, how would you do it? Should there even be a health care system, or should each o us be on our own? Is society as a whole be responsible for those in poverty?
Posted by preimert1 7 years, 11 months ago to Ask the Gulch
Previous comments... You are currently on page 2.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0087925/
I used to read that strip in a galaxy far, far away a long time ago.
Think I bought my last newspaper during 2013 and that was a rare event even then.
I'm pretty sure The Birmingham News didn't go for Pogo, though.
Part of being responsible is risk management - dealing with the potential/unexpected. That means private insurance according to one's risk factors and needs. but ONLY private enterprise can sufficiently craft a plan that maximizes my coverage while minimizing my outlays. Note that this does not mean I get to demand a Cadillac plan and pay nothing. For the same reason I purchase automobile insurance and homeowner's insurance, I purchase healthcare insurance.
Now, I do believe, however, that there should be two kinds of healthcare insurance and that much of the problem with our current system is the failure to recognize these. First, there is what should be called catastrophic insurance. That's what covers you if you find out you have cancer or get in an automobile accident. These are the rare but really expensive cases that really qualify as "insurance".
The second kind isn't really insurance at all, but health maintenance costs. These are the items people want covered under an insurance plan which aren't either catastrophic or rare: things like routine checkups at the doctor's office, getting an initial diagnosis of the flu, etc. Those shouldn't be termed insurance at all because they are routine. These items should be paid for out-of-pocket so as to reduce their actual consumption and bring it back into the realm where then products and services can be created to assist. This is where your company can purchase group services to specific doctors or groups for a negotiated rate for these basic services. (This was done a century ago.)
So that's how I'd do it.
Encourage physicians' cooperatives, with patients paying a subscription fee for all non-surgical treatment. A coop in Tulsa, OK charges its patients $50/month for a family, and sells them prescriptions at their cost. They accept no insurance for their services, but will connect patients with insurers who sell catastrophic coverage to cover surgeries and critical care. The cooperative is financially sound.
Make the cost of health care 100% tax deductible, including the insurance premiums for those who want insurance. This will help people with serious preexisting conditions.
Expand the use of HSAs, as noted by handyman.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MhtN4...
The insurance companies would be free to sell to any buyer anywhere. Agents would be able to combine coverage from any insurer or provider. And no policy would ever be locked to an employer, although group discounts might be.
Simply put, in this day of information, transparency would rule. The government's only involvement would be to prosecute criminality.
SUMMARY https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill...
For I hold that one can trace a lot of chronic illness to flat-out bad medical advice. People get that advice because the ones giving it have the licenses. But the advice is still bad.
More broadly: a government exists to manage force. It does not exist to provide goods and service that go beyond being the final arbiter of the use of force.
Adding my opinion: They took a system that isn't motivated to have healthy citizens (quite the opposite), a system that has the least efficient delivery of services (I pay $2500/month while my pediatrician gets $9/kid), slapped a level of government bureaucracy on top of it, held a gun to our heads and called it a tax. OH YEAH...THAT'S GOING TO WORK OUT WELL!
This really summarizes it. It seems like politicians are like a kid trying to arrange a set of coins on a table in a creative way that makes them have more buying power.
How he will overcome that corrupt century old or older elite establishment all dug in like infamous Alabama ticks?
I just don't know. Almost all of that crowd started out as conniving blood-sucking lawyers.
The Kim Jong Un way of doing things just doesn't go around here.
I was naive enough at one time to think that you could fight city hall....maybe I watched "Mr. Smith Goes to Washington" too often. Now, I really don't have much hope. I think that the Democrats are laughing at us little people, and so are the Republicans.
Load more comments...